The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe
Executive presence is the sort of judgment colleagues form about you in Cincinnati boardrooms and hallways without ever putting it on paper. You hear that you need more of it, no one can explain what it looks like, and before long you are second-guessing your blazers. Pause there. The people assessing it are really weighing three things: whether they can hand you a decision, whether you are listened to when you speak, and whether you hold your composure when things go sideways. Your wardrobe is not on that list. The fuzziness isn't accidental either. Studies on the likability penalty keep finding that the same request is heard as assertive coming from a man and as demanding coming from a woman, and "presence" is a convenient place for that bias to hide.
The review
Think back over the last month and respond with a simple yes or no. Tally only what genuinely occurred, not what you merely hoped you had done.
Item 1. Whenever you offer a recommendation, lead with the conclusion and follow with the rationale behind it.
Item 2. In a meeting, you voiced a dissenting view aloud to a senior colleague.
Item 3. Your team's purpose can be captured in a single sentence that someone outside the work would immediately understand.
Item 4. Whenever a problem surfaces, colleagues bring it to you first, before taking it anywhere else.
Item 5. In meetings you allow silence to linger rather than scrambling to break it.
Item 6. You admitted, "I don't know yet, but I'll have an answer by Thursday," and then you delivered on that promise.
Item 7. The notes you send to senior leaders run briefer than the ones they send to you.
Item 8. When a senior request was not feasible, you declined it and gave your reason in one concise sentence.
Item 9. Even in a tense room, you kept your composure where others visibly lost theirs.
SHORT 10. At a later meeting, someone echoed one of your remarks back to you.
Reading your score
Eight to ten: a position solidly in place. Colleagues already regard you as a person who makes decisions. If you are still getting the feedback, ask who is offering it and what they actually mean, because it may have little to do with you.
Four to seven: still developing. Your judgment is sound and you already show some of the signal. What's missing is mostly speed and economy: the recommendation up front, the shorter email, the silence you leave alone while the room catches up.
Zero to three: competent but understated, as many leaders in Covington and Florence have discovered. Your work is solid, and the meeting room is left to determine what that work amounts to. That is not a character flaw. Plenty of us learned to present our reasoning before arriving at a conclusion, which served well in school but works differently in the boardroom.
Your path forward
Scoring eight to ten means that whenever you hear the word "presence" again, you should ask, "What exactly would you like to see differently in our next meeting?" and jot the response down. If there isn't one, you have learned something about the feedback itself.
A score of four to seven calls for a one-month experiment: begin each update by stating the decision you need in the opening sentence. Change nothing else. Notice how the room responds.
A score of zero to three suggests that at your next meeting you voice one brief disagreement with the most senior person in the room, then fall silent. One sentence is enough. Consider opening with, "Here is where I stand and why," then pause so they can weigh in. Your influence shows most clearly in the moment of silence that follows your remark.
Add up your yes responses, and share this with the woman in your circle who was told she lacked presence but was never told what that meant.